ePoster
Talk Description
Institution: Monash Health - Victoria, Australia
Goal of review:
This systematic review evaluates functional or survival outcomes of Submandibular gland (SMG) preservation versus conventional SMG-sacrificing neck dissection.
Introduction:
SMG removal is traditionally performed during level 1B neck dissection for oral cavity squamous cell carcinoma (OCSCC). Although oncological outcomes are validated, there is limited information on functional outcomes.
Methods:
This review was registered prospectively on PROSPERO CRD420251038892. Systematic review of MEDLINE, Embase, Scopus, CINAHL, and grey literature from inception to April 2025 using MeSH terms pertaining to “Submandibular gland” and “Neck dissection”. All studies examining SMG-preserving neck dissection in OCSCC were included. Primary outcomes were functional outcomes (xerostomia, speech, voice). Risk of bias was assessed using ROBINS-I.
Results: Of 439 studies, five met inclusion criteria, comprising 421 patients (194 SMG-sparing, 228 SMG-sacrificing). Xerostomia outcomes were reported in all studies; two demonstrated statistically significant improvement in salivary function with SMG preservation, and two found no sustained difference. Speech and swallow outcomes were reported in one study each, suggesting improvement in both. One study reported improved swallowing scores, with no significant difference in speech outcomes. Study quality was at moderate to serious risk of bias, with small sample sizes and methodological heterogeneity precluding meta-analysis.
Discussion
Evidence for functional benefit from SMG preservation suggests reduced xerostomia, although findings remain inconsistent. Standardised patient-reported outcome measures are needed.
Conclusion:
SMG-sparing neck dissection may reduce postoperative xerostomia in OCSCC. Further research on swallowing or speech outcomes is required. Prospective studies using validated patient-reported outcome measures and international collaborations will strengthen future recommendations.
Speakers
Contributors
Authors
Dr Esther Chung - , Dr Seraphina Key - , Dr Matthew Kwok - , Dr Matthew Magarey -
